Who was ר' מאיר בעל הנס ?
One of the most ingenious
innovation
in Tzedaka fundraising was to
attach the
name of ר' מאיר בעל הנס to the Pushke and
placing
it in every Jewish home.
It
is unknown who came up with this brilliant idea.
It
is also unknown who
this ר'
מאיר בעל הנס
was.
Contrary
to the popular belief of most, it is not the
Tanna R.Meir.
The Sefer Zichron Yakov
(vol 2 p 30) writes ,
"The pushkes
were named after an Ish Chasid
V’kadosh who
lived in Eretz Hakodesh a
few
hundred years ago. He was
famous – and
was called ר'
מאיר בעל הנס”.
According to the Yerushalmi
(Kelaim 9:3), R. Meir died in
Chutz La'aretz (Place called Asia)
and his body was placed
in the sea in Chu"l.
One of the first sources that
mention R. Meir’s burial place
in E. Y. is in the Sefer Gelilos Eretz Yisroel. He writes that
R. Meir is buried
in the city of Tveryah.
The Seder Hadoros quotes
the same Sefer Gelilos Haaretz
who writes, "
R. Yitzchok from
Gush Chalav and
ר'
מאיר בעל הנס are both buried in Gush Chalav. The
Gelilos Haaretz continues that he doesn’t know who
the
two
were.
Two
of the most prominent and respected Frum historians
(R.
Yechiel Heilprin- Seder Hadoros & R.
Yaakov Lipschutz -
Zichron Yaakov )
both believed , that ר'
מאיר בעל הנס
and the Tanna R.Meir were two
different people.
1) R.M. is buried
in Tveryah RMBH is buried in Gush Chalav
2) Seder Hadoros
& Gelilos Haaretz don’t know who R.M.B.H.
was
3) Zichron Yaakov claims R.M.B.H.
lived a few hundred years ago
R.M.
lived two thousand years ago.
4) To
donate L’iluy Nishmas a Tanna who
was niftar 2,000 years
ago sounds strange. A Neshama of 2000 years has
reached it’s peak a long time ago.
5) Why do the other
hundreds of Tanoim & Amoraim most of whom
were also, מלומדים בנסים yet their Neshama doesn't need
an Aliyah
6) The Loshon, Baal Haness is
not found in Shas. In Gemoro
,
we only find the term
Melumad Banisim.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.