R.
Kruspedai in the name of R. Yochanan said, "Three Seforim
are opened on
Rosh Hashana."
Tzadikim
Gemurim are written and sealed to life immediately (on R.H)
Reshoim
Gemorim are written and sealed to death immediately (on R.H.)
Beinonim are
hanging in limbo until Yom Kippur and then written and
sealed on
(Yom Kippur)
The Piyut
said on R.H. & Y.K. “ בראש השנה יכתבון וביום צום כיפור יחתמון”
On whom is
this said?
Tzadikim
& Reshoim have both the Kesivah & Chasima On R. H.
Binonim
have both the Kesivah & Chasima on Y.K.
Who
has the Kesivah on Rosh Hashana and the Chasima on Yom Kippur?
3 answers:
A) The Paytan argues with R. Kruspadoai and holds that
all have the Kesiva on Rosh Hashanah and the Chasima on Yom Kippur.
B) The Beinonim can have their Kesiva on day 1 or day
2 -3 -4 etc. until Yom Kippur (depending when
he did Teshuva) Some Beinonim have the Kesiva on R.H.
and others have it on Y.K. but all Beinonim
have the Chasima on Y.K. (Maharsha R.H.)
C) For Yechidim (individuals ) The Kesiva & Chasima
happens the same day (Tzadikim & Reshoim on R.H.
and Beinonim on Y.K.)
For the Tzibbur (Kehilla, City, Country etc.) If the Tzibbur
is Beinoni, The Kesiva is on R.H. and the
Chasima on Y.K. ( Shu"t Mahram Shik O.Ch. 300)
3 answers:
A) The Paytan argues with R. Kruspadoai and holds that
all have the Kesiva on Rosh Hashanah and the Chasima on Yom Kippur.
B) The Beinonim can have their Kesiva on day 1 or day
2 -3 -4 etc. until Yom Kippur (depending when
he did Teshuva) Some Beinonim have the Kesiva on R.H.
and others have it on Y.K. but all Beinonim
have the Chasima on Y.K. (Maharsha R.H.)
C) For Yechidim (individuals ) The Kesiva & Chasima
happens the same day (Tzadikim & Reshoim on R.H.
and Beinonim on Y.K.)
For the Tzibbur (Kehilla, City, Country etc.) If the Tzibbur
is Beinoni, The Kesiva is on R.H. and the
Chasima on Y.K. ( Shu"t Mahram Shik O.Ch. 300)
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.