Carlebach vs Modzitz אליהו הנביא

 

Carlebach vs Modzitz אליהו הנביא The לקט יושר writes, his Rebbe the תרומת הדשן wouldn't sing the Piyut "אליהו הנביא" on Motzei Shabbos in the ספירה except if Lag Baomer  falls on  Motzei Shabbos. הרה"ג ר' שלמה זלמן אויערבך זצ"ל said  " The Terumas Hadeshen's  Niggun for  "אליהו הנביא"  must have been a Lebediker Niggun (Carlebach) that might  lead to dancing. Had it  been a slow Niggun (Modzitz)  then it would not have been a problem to  sing during the ספירה being it wouldn't lead to dancing."