Tuesday, March 12, 2024

Ah Shvere Kashyeh

 The Gemoro (.מגילה יד) says קרייתא זו הלילה. The reading of the 

מגילה is considered as the saying of הלל. Therefore we
don’t need to say
הלל on Purim.

The
מאירי says, that if someone didn't read (hear) the מגילה,
he must say
הלל on Purim. (so at least he will be יוצא מצוות הלל)

The Gemoro (18b) says that
ר' מאיר didn’t have a מגילה on Purim, 
so he wrote one by heart. 

Shu”t Chasam Sofer O.Ch. 192) R. Yehuda Osad zt"l asked,
"According to the
מאירי, ר' מאיר should have said הלל instead
of writing a whole
מגילה?"

The
חת"ס answered him that saying הלל is only בדיעבד.

My Eidem R. Yoni asked, "The '
קושי doesn't even begin
and the answer of the
חת"ס is not to be understood.

All the Gemoro says is, by reading the
מגילה you were יוצא the
 
מצוות הלל and not that by saying הלל you are יוצא קריאת מגילה"

The Shver iz gebliben mit the Shvere Kashyeh
ומצוה ליישב

No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

%60 OFF + COUPON ALERT COUPON CODE HIJKIVRU Teeth Whitening Kit Gel Pen Strips

  Teeth Whitening Kit Gel Pen Strips - Hydrogen Carbamide Peroxide for Sensitive Teeth, Gum,Braces Care 32X LED Light Tooth Whitener, Profes...