Wednesday, November 2, 2022

How Did The Steipler know the Rosh Yeshiva was drunk? ANSWER HERE

 There  once was a Rosh Yeshiva 

who said on Purim that  they can ask him 
any question in ש"ס and he will have an answer.

They asked him from the גמרא נדרים דף ח  a+b
"If someone dreamt that he was put in חרם and
they were also מתיר his חרם , he must be מתיר
his חרם  again after awakening. 

Because
we must assume part of the dream might be true and part not to be true, We assume the true part of the dream was being put in חרם and the untrue part of the dream was they were מתיר him".

They asked from the Rosh Yeshiva,
"why don't we assume the opposite, that the untrue 
part was being put in חרם and the true part
was them being מתיר the חרם, and he wouldn't 
need another היתר after awakening?

The R.Yeshiva answered that according to
the ראשונים who hold חרם  is דאורייתא and even if it is
only דברי קבלה, when there is a   ספק we need to go
לחומרא and assume he was put in חרם and didn't
have a התרה

The Steipler said, " from the answer he gave,  you
can tell the Rosh Yeshivah was drunk."


The question doesn't even begin
( no need for the Rosh Yeshiva's answer}

The only possibility for part of the dream to

be true is if he was put into חרם.

If he wasn't put in חרם (untrue part) then
the התרה will also be untrue since there
was no חרם there is no התרה.

No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

WOW!! 53% OFF + a $50 COUPON TO CLIP SAVE BIG ON THIS Robot Vacuum and Mop

  At the time of posting the ZCWA Robot Vacuum, Robot Vacuum and Mop Works with WiFi,APP, Remote, 2 in 1 Robot Vacuum Cleaner Self Charging,...