There is a Minhag*, not to stand facing the בעל
(in front of the בימה) while he Leins (reads) the תוכחה.
*Another Minhag is that the עולה before the
the בימה immediately after his Aliya and doesn't wait for the
end of the next Aliya to do so.
The original Minhag, and in some Shuls even today,
when the Gabai wants to give an Aliyah to the בעל קריאה
he doesn't call him up by saying יעמוד פלוני ב"פ since he
is already standing there.
All he does is point at him to take the next Aliya.
Hence this is how the Minhag started for the בעל קריאה
to get the תוכחה since there is no need to call him up.
**The original Minhag was to put it in the contract that
the שמש needs to take the Aliya of the תוכחה.
The רמ"א writes to call up יעמוד מי שירצה (no
name) Whoever is
willing to take this Aliya. Hence, ***Minhag
Ashkenaz (Germany & Oberland) The עולה gets called
There was a minhag**** to make a special מי שברך for the עולה.
It said all the קללות should turn into ברכות for the עולה.
The מקור חיים writes that the מי שירצה is a חיוב to be עולה
on the first day of Rosh Hashana and on the first day of
Shavuos. ie: The מי שירצה is being compensated by
an Aliya on the first Yom Tov after the תוכחה
דפרקא,דרכי תשובה,מנחת אלעזר
(חפץ חיים (באור הלכה
unaware of this Minhag therefore
he mistakenly has a wrong
Pshat in the רמ"א. (He admits
it to be a דוחק)
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.