This unbelievable story is
not to be believed, because
If this or a
similar שאלה were to have been asked from any Rav,
there is no way the Rav would
come up with such a Psak.
If the Chevra Kadisha
accepted money for a particular grave
and decides to cheat him, the
onus is on the Chevra Kadisha
to do Teshuva by placing
him in the grave he originally
purchased, regardless who is
next to him.
There is no need for the
Niftar to attend a Din Torah and there
is no need for the
Niftar to remove himself from the old grave
and bury himself in the
new one etc.
The Chasam Sofer writes if
you mix Halacha with Nistar (Kabala) you end up with Kelaim
(Shatnez)
Here too if you mix a
Chasidishe/Kabalistic story with a
Psak from the Bach (Ish
Halacha) you end up with Kelaim.
(Halacha that doesn't make
any sense)
.
The real* story was: The
Megaleh Amukos had a son R. Yitzchok
who was Niftar at a young
age. He was buried next to his
father the M.A.. Over the
years his Matzeiva disintegrated.
The Chevra Kadisha decided to
replace it with a new one.
The script on the old
Matzeiva was illegible.Very little was
known about him so they wrote
on the Matzeiva "Yagid Olov Reio"
The fact that he was buried
next to his great father proves he
must have been a great man
.
* I have personally seen a
picture of the Yagid Olov Reio
Matzeiva, taken before the
war. (WW2) The name" R. Yitzchok "
son of the M.A. is clearly
legible
This version of the story
was supposedly recorded in the
Pinkas of the Krakower Chevra Kadisha
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.