Tuesday, January 6, 2015

R.Yeshaya Pik's (Berlin) bomb* Kushya-Parshas Shmos

                                                                                                                                                               לז"נ הקדוש ר' אברהם אשי בן הרב שמואל הי"ד
                                                                                                                                                    ט"ו טבת
          כי מתו כל האנשים
Rashi quotes the Gemoro in Nedarim 64b that מתו refers to losing all their money, because
   ד' חשובין כמת, עני ,ומצורע ,וסומא ושאין לו בנים
The   ר"ן (7b) explains how  we know that
they lost their money and not they became
  מצורעים . because it says  during the Machlokes
of Korach they were **בקרב כל ישראל
Had they have been מצורעים they would
have been מחוץ למחנה . Even though during
Matan Torah all  of Bnei Yisroel were healed
(so it’s possible to have been a מצורע in
Mitzrayim and by Korach healed and Tahor.)
This can’t be, because during the  מעשה עגל
all  original sicknesses  etc. returned.
Therefore we must say since they were not
מצורעים during Korach they were also not
מצורעים in Mitzrayim.
The Sheilos Sholom*** on the Sheiltos (P.Metzora)
asks, The Mishna in Nega’im Perek 7 learns
from a Pasuk, If someone had a  צרעת before
Matan Torah he does not become Tomei after
Matan Torah. According to the Ran after the
עגל must be considered as a פנים חדשות and
not as the original from before Matan Torah.
therefore they would have been Tomei.
If so,for when does the Torah exclude a  צרעת
from before Matan Torah.(to beTahor)
From Matan Torah till the עגל  there were no מצורעים
 After the עגל we say that it is considered a new צרעת
and he would be טמא. So what is the Pasuk teaching
us?

No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

ONLY $9.99!!! ETHANOL Mens Comfy Stretch Slim Fit Straight Casual Pants with 5 Pockets Design Pants

  ETHANOL Mens Comfy Stretch Slim Fit Straight Casual Pants with 5 Pockets Design Pants