The Bach Y.D. 217 quotes the Teshuvas R. Chaim Paltiel *1, "Making a Neder
to go to the Bais Hakevoros, sounds a little like Doresh El Hameisim.
Kalev ben Yefune when he davened at the Mearat Hamachpeila,
davened directly to Hashem and not to the Avos. The reason he davened there
was , it being a Makom Kadosh.
Women and men who aren't aware of this, for them I don't see any purpose
going to a Bais Hakevoros." (He was matir the Neder).
The Bach continues, that today the minhag to go to Kivrei Tzadikim and no one
is Mochè (objects)
There are some Mamorei Chazal, Zohar Sefer Chasidim and others who
do allow to daven directly to the Meisim to be a Meilitz Yosher .
Most Pokim*2 hold, you may not daven to the Meism to interfere on your behalf.
The second problem of davening in a Bais Hakevoros is, Loèg Lèrosh (embarrassing
It says in Shulchan Aruch (344-17), The only time you are allowed to say Pesukim or
Dvar Torah in front of a Meis or in a Bais Hakevoros, is when you are saying it
Lekovod Hameis. Davening for your own sake is problematic because of Loeg Lèrosh.
The Shu"t Minchas Elozor ( #3- 53) attempts to justify, Davening at Kivrei Tzadikim.
The Satmarer Rebbe R. Yoel Teitelbaum zt"l (Al Hageulah Vèal Hatemurah 108)
writes, visiting Kivrei Tzadikim is only for people who understand and know how
to connect with the Tzadik. For the masses there is no point to go to Kivrei Tzadikim.
*1 Ba'alei Tosfos
* 2Rambam (Pirush Hamishnayos P. Chelek)- Sefer Haikrim (17)- Levush- Maharal - Maharil
Chayei Adam- R. Chaim Volozhin - Chasam Sofer- Mishna Verura etc.
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.