Daf Hashavua
Eruvin 64 a
Dr. Judah told me, he once asked his father in law (R. P.
Hirshprung zt"l)
The gemara says If one wants to take leave from his friend, he
should do
so by saying a dvar halacha, doing so, he will remember him.
He asked who is the one that is supposed to say the dvar halacha
and who
remembers. Is it the one that stays on or the one who leaves.*
R.Hirshprung answered that probably
the the one who is leaving says
the dvar halacha and the one who stays on, remembers.
Dr. Judah asked him maybe the opposite. R. Hirshprung answered yes
could be the opposite. (The one who stays on says the dvar halacha
etc.)
D.J. asked again maybe both have to say the dvar halacha. R.S.
answered
yes could be so.
D.J. said " I am surprised at the schver that he dosn't have
an answer
from the gemara". R.S. asked him which seder in shas would he
find
the answer. D.J. said that he wants to make it easier for the
schver.
The answer is based on a gemara in eiruvin.
It didn't take more than a few seconds and Rabbi Hirshprung said
yes you are right the answer is in eiruvin 64a at the bottom of
the amud.
(answer both)
* Seems from the Maharsha (Brachos 31a) the one who
leaves says the dvar Halacha.
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.