Monday, October 22, 2012

6 different Shemonei Esrei


Six meshulochim  arrived  from E. Yisrael.  Each one had to daven a different
Shemone Esrei .

*Answer:
1)      E.Y. started  saying  “v’sein tal umotor”   Monday evening 7 marcheshvan
       2)    Chutz Laaretz   starts saying  “v’sein tal umotor”  on Dec 4 (evening)
3)      Tuesday  7 Cheshven  is one of the  fast days  mentioned in megilas taanis and
Shulchan aruch  O.ch. 580 - 1 (those fasting say aneinu)

                                      Halacha v’lo lemaaseh
Six meshulochim  A, A1, B, B1,  C,  and  C1  all live in E.Yisrael and travelled to  Chutz Laaretz.
Mincha  on Tuesday 7  Cheshvan  , each one had to  daven a  different Shemonei.Esrei.

A, arrived on Monday   6 Cheshvon and plans to stay till Dec 5 (or longer)
A, says  v’sein brocho
A 1, arrived on Monday   6 Cheshvon and plans to stay till Dec 5 (or longer)  & fasts
A1,  says  v’sein brocho  & aneinu
B,   arrived  on Monday  6 Cheshvon and plans to return before Dec.4
B, says “v’sein brocho “  and at  shma koleinu he must also say  v’sein tal umotor” 
B1  arrived  on Monday  6 Cheshvon and plans to return before Dec.4  & fasts
B,1 says “v’sein brocho “  and at  shma koleinu he must also say  v’sein tal umotor”  & aneinu

C, left  E.Y.  on Tuesday morning   7 Cheshvon
C, says  “v’sein tal umotor” 
C1, left E.Y.  on Tuesday morning   7 Cheshvon & fasts
C1, says  “v’sein tal umotor”  & aneinu

Summary :    
A says v’sein brocho –
A 1 says v’sein brocho & aneinu
  
B  says v’sein brocho &v’sein tal umotor” 
B 1 says v’sein brocho &v’sein tal umotor”  & aneinu.

C says “ v’sein tal umotor”  “
C1 says” v’sein tal umotor”  & aneinu

*Teshuvos v’hanhogos vol 2 (R. M. Sternbuch shlita) -  Rabbi Yosef Koval shlita Cleveland Hts. OH.

PS. R. B. Lampert answered where the B & B1  came from  a country that
has opposite seasons than E.Y.(south America  etc.)  and rain is needed  at  that time, then
you have to say v’sein brocho and tal umotor at shma koleinu.




No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

-43% Cricut Beveled Blank Mug

  https://amzn.to/3yE186v