האיך
בני אדם מותרים בנשותיהם בלילה
אלא
בטביעות עינא דקלא
The Gemoro assumes, spouses may live
together
at night without being able to see each other (to be sure
it is not a stranger) because of טביעות עינא דקלא (voice recognition).
The Ramban (Breishis 27:12) asks “Why wasn’t Yakov
afraid of Yitzchok recognizing his voice not being same
as Eisav’s ?. If simple people can recognize טביעות עינא דקלא
then for sure Yitzchok the Chacham would.
The Ramban answers two Tirutzim. a) The two brothers
had similar voices (twins) b) Yakov was able to imitate
Eisav’s voice.
According to the Ramban's
answers, how do we understand
our Gemoro that allows living together at night
because of טביעות עינא דקלא How
does it help, if you can have
two people with same voice or
one imitating someone else’s voice.
????
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.