Thursday, October 8, 2015

Is A Yartzheit A Happy Day ? REPOSTED IN HONOR OF THE CHASAM SOFERS YAHRTZEIT

FAST OR FEST- IVAL

 The Chasam Sofer writes (Parshas Emor –Hesped) about an argument he had with Reb  Efraim Zalmen Margulios:

“We don’t find anywhere (in Chazal) to make a Yom Tov on the Yahrzeit of a Tzaddik. On the contrary, we find in Chazal, to fast on the day a parent* or a Rebbe dies.” 


The Chasam Sofer explains when the Zohar calls it Yoma d’Hilulla, it is referring to Shomayim. 

Only in heaven are they happy when a Tzadik arrives there. 

In this world it is a sad day and fasting is in order.

The Sdei Chemed writes: he heard the Toras Chesed (R. Shnier Zalmen Lublin- Liadi) said  the Chasam Sofer  missed a Befeirishe Rashi ( Yevamos 122a D.H. Teloso Rigla)

Rashi explains “Rigla Deamorei” in Teshuvas Hageonim, he found, that on the day an Odom Gadol dies, they institute that day for Talmidei Chachamim to gather and establish a Yeshiva at his grave.

We see from here that it is called a Regel (Yom Tov)

The Sdei Chemed writes, “he can’t believe the Peh Kadosh (Toras Chesed) would have made such a statement (missed a Rashi) on the Chasam Sofer.

Where do we find Rashi, disagreeing with the Chasam Sofers argument, against partying and turning the day of Misas Tzadikim into a Simcha & Yom Tov.”



*It is interesting, the Chasam Sofers Rebetzin wrote in her Tzavo’oh, not to fast on her Yahrzeit. (Bitul Torah)

1 comment:

  1. "*It is interesting, the Chasam Sofers Rebetzin wrote in her Tzavo’oh, not to fast on her Yahrzeit. (Bitul Torah)"

    That was her personal choice. Maybe she knew her children, maybe they were shvach and their learning would be seriously affected negatively. A parent can be mochel on their kavod. Note that she didn't write against the minhag of fasting on a yahrzeit in general, overall.

    ReplyDelete

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

-29% Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water Bottle PET, 16 Oz, 6-Pack

  Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water Bottle PET, 16 Oz, 6-Pack