Monday, May 5, 2014

two dinim

Perhaps, We can breakdown  The Bracha L’vatala into  two dinim.
1.      When making a Bracha L., you are oiver an Issur. ( Lo Sisa Shaim-)
2.       The Bracha you made, is an invalid Bracha.
If some one makes a Bracha “ Al Achilas Matza” and is Motzie
others with his Bracha , but he drops dead before he eats the Matzah,
It is possible, that the others have to make a new Bracha before eating
their Matzah. They were not Yotze with the Bracha,the
dead man made , being the Bracha  was a Bracha L. (#2 invalid Bracha)

Even though the dead man wasn’t oiver the Issur (not his fault that he died),
but it is still considered an invalid Bracha.
The same would apply to someone who made a Bracha “Al Sefiras Haomer”
and drops dead before counting, his Bracha is L’vatala and not considered
a valid Bracha.
According to the Poskim who hold, " not finishing the 49 days (one Mitzvah)
       the Brachos he made in the past are L’vatala", the same would apply to  someone
       who dies during Sefira. His Brachos are considered L’vatala, only to invalidate

       them but not to be oiver on the Issur.

No comments:

Post a Comment

anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.

-66% Chef Craft Classic Cupcake Liners, 50 count, Black

  Chef Craft Classic Cupcake Liners, 50 count, Black