Six meshulochim arrived from E. Yisrael.
Each one had to daven a different
Shemone Esrei .
*Answer:
1)
E.Y. started
saying “v’sein tal umotor” Monday evening 7 marcheshvan
2) Chutz Laaretz starts saying
“v’sein tal umotor” on Dec 4 (evening)
3)
Tuesday 7
Cheshven is one of the fast days
mentioned in megilas taanis and
Shulchan aruch O.ch. 580 - 1 (those fasting say aneinu)
Halacha v’lo lemaaseh
Six meshulochim A, A1, B, B1, C, and C1
all live in E.Yisrael and travelled to Chutz Laaretz.
Mincha on Tuesday 7 Cheshvan , each one had to
daven a different Shemonei.Esrei.
A, arrived on Monday 6 Cheshvon and plans to stay till
Dec 5 (or longer)
A, says v’sein brocho
A 1, arrived on Monday 6 Cheshvon and plans to stay
till Dec 5 (or longer) & fasts
A1, says v’sein brocho & aneinu
B, arrived on Monday 6 Cheshvon and plans
to return before Dec.4
B, says “v’sein brocho “ and at shma koleinu he
must also say v’sein tal umotor”
B1 arrived on Monday 6 Cheshvon and plans to
return before Dec.4 & fasts
B,1 says “v’sein brocho “ and at shma koleinu
he must also say v’sein tal umotor” & aneinu
C, left E.Y. on Tuesday morning 7 Cheshvon
C, says “v’sein tal umotor”
C1, left E.Y. on Tuesday morning 7 Cheshvon
& fasts
C1, says “v’sein tal umotor” & aneinu
Summary :
A says v’sein
brocho –
A 1 says v’sein brocho & aneinu
B says v’sein brocho &“v’sein tal umotor”
B 1 says v’sein brocho &“v’sein tal umotor”
& aneinu.
C says “ v’sein tal umotor” “
C1 says” v’sein
tal umotor” & aneinu
*Teshuvos v’hanhogos vol 2 (R.
M. Sternbuch shlita) - Rabbi Yosef Koval shlita Cleveland
Hts. OH.
PS. R. B. Lampert answered where the B & B1
came from a country that
has opposite seasons than E.Y.(south America etc.) and
rain is needed at that time, then
you have to say v’sein brocho and tal umotor at shma koleinu.
