Perhaps we can answer the
Kushya on the Rosh,
that there is a
difference between Halacha & Agada.
In Halacha The Torah tells
you to count 50 days or give
40 Malkos. Torah shel bal peh
tells us the number
50 & 40 are inaccurate
and should be 49 & 39 there
we must say the number is
inaccurate and rounded off
to the nearest 10.
In Agadah, Chazal have more
leeway to Darshen the
inaccurate number and explain
it as accurate according
to Drush and not to use the
explanation of rounding off.
The only problem with this
answer is, the Rosh uses
also an example of Agada. The
70 Nefashos going
down to Mitzrayim.
The truth is there too*
Chazal (Bava Basra 123b)answer
that by counting
Yocheved who was born between the
walls (border) the
number seventy is correct. (ambzy)
*see Korban Nesanel
No comments:
Post a Comment
anything that is not relevant to the post will be marked as spam.